Open main menu

OrthodoxWiki β

Changes

Talk:Compline

678 bytes added, 11:05, March 23, 2007
Roman Scholars referenced in this article
:Ok, but I wasn't disputing the message so much as the sources. Could it be rewritten without citing obscure Catholic scholars, maybe? [[User:Gabriela|Gabriela]] 20:47, March 22, 2007 (PDT)
 
::The only ways I could see doing it are to either greatly abbreviate the section, and to just state generally the broad consensus of scholars, or for someone to re-write it, and cite more recent scholars who have covered the same ground. The first option results in less information... and I think the information is useful and interesting. The second option would prehaps be an improvement, but you would still largely (if not exclusively) be talking about the findings of non-Orthodox scholars -- unless there is someone who is familiar with contemporary Greek scholarship on this issue, which have some uniquely Orthodox ideas on the matter. -Fr. John Whiteford 3-23-07
1,352
edits