7,257
edits
Changes
m
→Problems with the text: add link
The most obvious problem with the text is one of dating. It claims to be regarding either the 19th or 20th centuries with varying levels of internal consistency in the actual text. Some, for instance, read "After the year 1900, toward the middle of the 19th century," which is contradictory, since starting with the year 1901, the 20th century began. Additionally, with several different versions circulating, especially with variances in this key opening phrase, it would seem that the text has been altered, so one cannot be sure about the period it supposedly is addressing.
The claim that the ''Prophecy'' is from the 4th century is also problematic, as in the 4th century it was not yet the practice of Christians to date from the [[Nativity|birth of Christ]], a practice introduced only in the 6th century by Dionysius Exiguus ("the Short"), a Roman [[monk]]. In the 4th century, dating was still calculated from the [[Creation]], the founding of Rome, from the accession of the current emperor, or from the time of [[Diocletian ]] according to the [[Indiction]]. Even after its introduction by Dionysius, it did not come into general use in the West until the 8th century.
Eastern Christians waited even longer to use the Nativity as a dating point. Most Orthodox Christians began the practice only after the [[fall of Constantinople]], while the [[Church of Russia]] introduced it only with the time of Tsar Peter the Great (16th/17th c.).
